Abraham the Polytheist?


More interesting thoughts from Karen Armstrong’s A History of God. In discussing the origins of monotheism, she presents a more nuanced view than what I learned growing up. I always assumed that while a lot of the early figures in Genesis (like Adam and Noah) knew God, by the time of Abraham most people were polytheists, and Abraham correctly recognized that there was only one God. (All of this assumes that these figures were actual people and not legends. Adam and Noah are certainly legendary, since there was no first man, and no Flood, while Abraham’s historicity is disputable, though somewhat irrelevant.)

Armstrong’s view is based partly on the different names and actions recorded for God in the Pentateuch. Because the Pentateuch came from several different sources (the Documentary Hypothesis) that were later edited together, we can overlook the differences between the God of the J (Jahwist), E (Elohist), and other later sources. The similarities between some of the actions and attributes ascribed to these gods and those used to describe other ancient gods can be striking. What is the better conclusion, that Abraham and subsequent monotheists recognized that these attributes all pointed to a deity who was there all along, or that Abraham and his fellows were very much a product of their times, and we reinterpret them based on later Jewish, Christian or Islamic understandings of God? The line between monotheism and polytheism really isn’t quite so clear. Armstrong writes:

We are so familiar with the Bible story and the subsequent history of Israel that we tend to project our knowledge of later Jewish religion back onto these early historical personages. Accordingly, we assume that the three patriarchs of Israel—Abraham, his son Isaac and his grandson Jacob—were monotheists, that they believed in only one God. This does not seem to have been the case. Indeed, it is probably more accurate to call these early Hebrews pagans who shared many of the religious beliefs of their neighbors in Canaan. They would certainly have believed in the existence of such deities as Marduk, Baal and Anat. They may not all have worshipped the same deity: it is possible that the God of Abraham, the “Fear” or “Kinsman” of Isaac and the “Mighty One” of Jacob were three separate gods.

We can go further. It is highly likely that Abraham’s God was El, the High God of Canaan. The deity introduces himself to Abraham as El Shaddai (El of the Mountain) which was one of El’s traditional titles. Elsewhere he is called El Elyon (The Most High God) or El of Bethel. The name of the Canaanite High God is preserved in such Hebrew names as Isra-El or Ishma-El. They experienced him in ways that would not have been unfamiliar to the pagans of the Middle East.

Later, Armstrong writes about the relatively frequent occurrence of ‘epiphanies’ in ancient cultures:

[While the Israelites found the “holiness” of Yahweh a terrifying experience], [in comparison] Abraham’s god El is a very mild deity. He appears to Abraham as a friend and sometimes even assumes human form. This type of divine apparition, known as an epiphany, was quite common in the pagan world of antiquity… The Iliad is full of such epiphanies…The world was full of gods, who could be perceived unexpectedly at any time, around any corner or in the person of a passing stranger. It seems that ordinary folk may have believed that such divine encounters were possible in their own lives: this may explain the strange story in the Acts of the Apostles when, as late as the first century CE, the apostle Paul and his disciple Barnabas were mistaken for Zeus and Hermes by the people of Lystra in what is now Turkey.

I’ve asked my friends before this question: If you ran into Paul tomorrow, fresh from the road to Damascus, and he told you he had seen a light and a vision and received a message from God, would your response be to believe him to be a balanced, sane person who should be listened to, or merely the product of either mental illness or a radically different culture? For those who insist that such visions and revelations once occurred, but simply haven’t in recent years, I would suggest that this sort of epiphanous revelation of God is still quite common in other cultures (such as much of Africa). I think if I’m honest with myself and my worldview, I would be just as skeptical of Paul as I am that the lives of the Africans I know are actually controlled by ancestors, demons, or other spirits.

Julia Sweeney, a standup comedian, performs a one-woman play entitled “Letting Go of God.” I highly recommend this clip of the play available at TED Talks, where she talks about realizing the oddity of doctrines such as the virgin birth after being visited by Mormon missionaries. If they can believe such absurdities about Joseph Smith, the book of Mormon, and Native Americans, she wondered, should she be more critical of her own beliefs?

Again, on the commonality of things that we would find ridiculous in the Old Testament:

In Chapter 18 of Genesis, J tells us that God appeared to Abraham by the oak tree of Mamre, near Hebron. Abraham had looked up and noticed three strangers approaching his tent during the hottest part of the day. With typical Middle Eastern courtesy, he insisted that they sit down and rest while he hurried to prepare food for them. In the course of conversation, it transpired, quite naturally, that one of these men was none other than his god, whom J calls “Yahweh.” The other two men turn out to be angels. Nobody seems particularly surprised by this revelation.


19 Responses to Abraham the Polytheist?

  1. Cody says:

    At the very least Abraham believed that his God was one among many. If you pay attention to the stories of the Hebrew Bible you notice that other gods are not denied, but called less powerful etc. The wars etc. in the Hebrew Bible can easily be seen as fights between gods being played out on earth through humans. This is all very interesting to me because of what I grew up believing. It isn’t exactly like what I was told as a youngster.

  2. Tim Cooke says:

    And you were around to witness this lack of first man and flood, I’m assuming? There is evidence for it everywhere. Just look at the great mountain ranges, all of which contain large amounts of fossilized sea creatures at the highest places. The lack of erosional features between rock layers, showing rapid depositiion. The exponential increase in population of the earth over the years can be traced back to not more than a few thousand years Before Christ, with the population being less than one third of what it is now as recent as a century ago, according to Wikipedia. And with Paul, that does sound a little crazy, but seeing how his life changed from that point on – from hating Christians and getting people to kill them, to being a leader of and father to them – has to beg the question: What happened to him on that journey?
    “For they are willingly ignorant of the fact that long ago by God’s word the heavens existed and the earth was formed out of water and by water. By these waters also the world of that time was deluged and destroyed. By the same word the present heavens and earth are reserved for fire, being kept for the day of judgment and destruction of ungodly people. (2 Peter 3:5–7).

  3. globalizati says:

    And you were around to witness this lack of first man and flood, I’m assuming?

    Yes, I was there – it was just, what, 60 years ago?

    Hehe, did you just call me ungodly?

  4. Jonathan says:

    The denial of a deluge was acceptable a decade ago, but it is no longer acceptable. Evidence of localized floods from various cultures who claim it “universal,” water damage on the Pyramids of Giza, as well as me personally (and anyone who explores mountain caves) finding sea shells in the Appalachian Mountains of Tennessee, USA – I think the deluge is quite probable.

  5. 论文代写 says:

    Hi, I would like to subscribe for this webpage to get most recent updates, thus where can i do it please help out.

  6. Jesse Grillo says:

    I have added your page to my Website I bet you sweat glitter.

  7. Jesse Grillo says:

    I will be sure to follow your other sites. Thanks for writing this. Oh my gosh! A great article.

  8. Admiring the commitment you put into your website and detailed information you offer. It’s nice to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same out of date rehashed material. Wonderful read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Google account.

  9. Excellent post but I was wondering if you could write a litte more on this subject? I’d be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Bless you!

  10. Admiring the time and energy you put into your blog and detailed information you offer. It’s great to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same old rehashed information. Fantastic read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.

  11. Joseph says:

    I would like to know how Abraham became the model of faith in God? Please explain me. Thanks.

  12. Joseph says:

    Second request is that I would like to know authors and dates of old testament of the holy bible.

  13. An impressive share, I just with all this onto a colleague who was simply conducting a little analysis with this. And hubby the truth is bought me breakfast since I discovered it for him.. smile. So i want to reword that: Thnx to the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending time to talk about this, I’m strongly about this and adore reading read more about this topic. Whenever possible, as you become expertise, could you mind updating your blog post with a lot more details? It can be extremely ideal for me. Huge thumb up for this short article!

  14. Really good blog,thank so much for your effort in writing the posts.

  15. Very good blog,thank you very much for your time in writing the posts.

  16. […] Abraham the Polytheist? | globalizati […]

  17. It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d definitely donate to this excellent blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to new updates and will share this blog with my Facebook group. Chat soon!

  18. I’m impressed, I must say. Seldom do I come across a blogthat’s equally educative and amusing, and without a doubt, you’vehit the nail on the head. The problem is somethingwhich not enough men and women are speaking intelligently about.I’m very happy I came across this in my hunt for something concerning this.

  19. Hi everybody! I was being curious whether anyone would like to sign up with me as a hemp and CBD goods reviewer? I have actually been given a ton of cbd goods from popular brands which include Hemp Hookahzz I likewise have a lot of CBD and hemp items to send out to CBD and hemp reviewers, consisting of CBD Terpenes, CBD Gummies and CBD Isolate I likewise do vape reviews and am seeking a vape reviewer also to review the following eliquid brands (will be shipped to you): Billy’s Best E-Juice, Crew Juice E-Juice and Strawmonhead By HomeTown Vapor Thanks guys and have a fabulous day! You can reach me at https://allcbdstores.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: